Capital mistake

A Cypriot reader of Babel drew my attention to what he considered ‘a big mistake’ in the Greek translation: my claim that Turkish is spoken in Northern Cyprus. ‘There is not a country named North Cyprus,’ he countered. ‘The northern part of the island is occupied and only recognised by the occupiers (Turkey).’

That’s true in my world as well. At the same time, it’s also a fact that most people in that unrecognised country speak Turkish. So where’s the big mistake? Could this be just another case of fact-free nationalism?

I was in the process of writing a puzzled reply when a possible explanation dawned on me, and checking the English and Greek editions of the book seemed to corroborate it. At first sight, the translation was immaculate: Northern Cyprus, Vóreios Kúpros. However, while words like Northern and Western are often written with a capital in English, Greek only seems to do so when they’re part of an established name. If the translator had written vóreios Kúpros, this simply would have meant ‘Northern Cyprus’, as in ‘the Northern part of the island called Cyprus.’ However, she committed the infelicity of using a capital V, Vóreios Kúpros, which placed this entity in the same category as Vóreia Koréa and Vóreia Makedonía—countries. Hence the reader’s protest.

Before I could even finish this short blogpost, my correspondent replied to confirm that that was exactly it. He was going to notify the publisher in Athens, he announced.

4 thoughts on “Capital mistake

  1. Not such a big mistake, but interesting, a bit bizarre and Greek, too:
    Why is Bayern, the German name of Bavaria, written with „y“?
    Today’s only correct spelling of the country name with “y” goes back to an order by King Ludwig I of Bavaria on October 20, 1825, with which the spelling “Baiern” that had been in force since 1806 was replaced. This order of the king to write with the “Greek” ypsilon is related to his philhellenism. (The first Greek king was a Bavarian.) Until then, the country name was often written with an “i”, although there are also many older records of the spelling with a “y”.
    The adjective „bairisch“ is almost always written with „i“.

    Liked by 1 person

    • That’s a great story! I was vaguely intrigued by the y. But since some other places have strange spellings as well (Soest, Thüringen, Cochem, and even stranger ones here in the Netherlands), I didn’t expect an interesting reason.

      Like

  2. This is such an intriguing article! Loved it! Only those who are deeply interested in linguistics, translation and – here – geopolitics can appreciate the subtle objection and the more than thorough answer. Thank you!

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a comment